Unraveling 'When We Believed in Mermaids' by Barbara O'Neal

Barbara O’Neal's 'When We Believed in Mermaids' book

Barbara O’Neal’s ‘When We Believed in Mermaids’ is an evocative narrative that delves deep into the realms of family, loss, and rediscovery. 

This article offers an insightful summary and analysis, exploring the intricacies of this poignant tale.

Expanding the Overview of ‘When We Believed in Mermaids’

The novel begins with a gripping line that sets the tone for an enthralling journey. The story revolves around Kit, who is stunned to see her sister, Josie, presumed dead for fifteen years, on a news broadcast. This sighting propels Kit on a quest to New Zealand, stirring a torrent of emotions and memories.

Critical Analysis of the Narrative

  • Plot Development: The novel’s plot unfolds through the alternating perspectives of Kit and Josie, enriching the reader’s understanding of both characters. This technique effectively illuminates their shared past, individual struggles, and the secrets that have shaped their lives;
  • Character Connection: While O’Neal’s prose is beautifully descriptive, some readers may find a lack of connection with the characters. The side plots, including a mysterious house with a murder history, though intriguing, seem underdeveloped and peripheral to the main storyline;
  • Exploring Emotional Depths: O’Neal adeptly captures the complexity of familial relationships, particularly the bond between the sisters, set against a backdrop of childhood secrets and traumas.

Thematic Elements in ‘When We Believed in Mermaids’

  • The Power of the Past: The story underscores how past experiences and secrets can profoundly influence one’s present life;
  • Journey of Self-Discovery: Both Kit and Josie embark on personal journeys, not just in physical terms but also in confronting their past and understanding their identities;
  • Resilience and Healing: The novel highlights the resilience of the human spirit and the possibility of healing, even after profound loss.

Diving Deeper into the Novel’s Core Themes

  • The Impact of Trauma: Analyzing how past traumas and unresolved issues play a central role in the characters’ development;
  • Setting as a Character: Exploring how the settings, from New Zealand’s landscapes to the familial environments, contribute to the novel’s mood and themes;
  • Interpersonal Dynamics: Examining the complex relationships between characters, including the nuances of sisterly bonds and romantic entanglements.

Literary Techniques in O’Neal’s Narrative

  • Use of Flashbacks: O’Neal employs flashbacks effectively to unravel the sisters’ past, adding layers to the narrative;
  • Symbolism and Imagery: Investigating the use of symbolism and vivid imagery in depicting emotional states and character development;
  • Narrative Pacing: Discussing the pacing of the story, its impact on reader engagement, and how it interplays with the unfolding of key plot points.

For those captivated by narratives exploring identity and the complexities of the past, ‘The Stranger in the Mirror’ by Liv Constantine offers a similarly enthralling journey into the mysteries of memory and self-discovery.

Conclusion

‘When We Believed in Mermaids’ by Barbara O’Neal is a compelling tale that weaves together themes of loss, love, and the enduring bonds of sisterhood. Through its intricate narrative and profound character exploration, the novel resonates deeply, leaving a lasting impact on its readers. 

O’Neal’s skillful storytelling invites us into a world where the past and present collide, revealing the power of memories and the resilience required to move forward.

Leave a Reply